Author |
Topic |
|
|
LessonsWithTroy Forum Newbie
United States
45 Posts |
|
|
Tom Jr.
Average Member
 
United States
182 Posts |
|
|
va picker
Forum Newbie
United States
39 Posts |
|
|
StephenSelby
Beginning Member

China
88 Posts |
|
|
Greg Booth
Forum Newbie
United States
44 Posts |
|
|
va picker
Forum Newbie
United States
39 Posts |
|
|
StephenSelby
Beginning Member

China
88 Posts |
|
|
wyattu
Average Member
 
United States
228 Posts |
|
|
Greg Booth
Forum Newbie
United States
44 Posts |
Posted - 02/09/2010 : 09:13:17
|
quote: Originally posted by StephenSelby how much of that is exotic chords and how much is coming from the imagination of the listener.....I'm just wondering whether it confirms my view that good dobro playing is the art of deception rather then very technical stuff with chords.
Stephen, one of the members here, StrawDavid, tabbed my arrangement out and posted it in the Tab archive. At first it there were a lot of mistakes but I see that he has fixed most of them and it is very close with only a few glitches now. I plan to get back to him soon, thank him and make some minor corrections.
http://www.hangoutstorage.com/resoh...11312010.ptb
It will play with the powertab viewer and you can hear the "exotic" chords.
[Am] [Fm6,] [C] [B7,] [Em7] [A] [Dm7] [G7] [C] Chestnuts roasting on an open fire [C6] [Dm7] [/g] [Cmaj79] [Dm7] [/g] Jack Frost nipping at your nose [C6] [Gm7] [C7] [F] [E7] Yuletide carols being sung by a choir [Am] [Fm6] [C] [F#m7] [B7] And folks dressed up like Eskimos [E] [Fm7] [Bb7] [Eb]
Your comment about deception and imagination, if I understand it, I don't disagree with, if by that you mean a few well chosen notes in a phrase can imply or convey a chord change. It isn't usually possible or necessary to play full exotic chords on the dobro, but if you know the recipe for the chord you can distill the essence and make it work. My point is that to interpret music like this on the dobro it helps to understand chord construction. I only chose this song because it was an example that is out there and accessible. |
 |
|
|
StephenSelby
Beginning Member

China
88 Posts |
|
|
Ride
Forum Newbie
Spain
46 Posts |
Posted - 02/10/2010 : 05:04:37
|
Great Troy!
Just a little comment. For me is not the same an Add9 chord and a Sus2 chord.
Add9 chord (as the name suggest) adds a 9th to the major triad, BUT CONSERVES THE 3RD, only adds a 9th (in fact, a 2nd) as tension, but the chords remains major.
On the other hand, a suspended chord (sus2 or sus4) haven't got the 3rd (so it's not a major nor a minor chord, but a suspended). The 3rd is substituted by the 2nd, root-2nd-5th (in sus2) and the 4th root-4th-5th (in sus4).
Ride
|
 |
|
|
LessonsWithTroy
Forum Newbie
United States
45 Posts |
|
|
StephenSelby
Beginning Member

China
88 Posts |
|
|
Greg Booth
Forum Newbie
United States
44 Posts |
|
|
StephenSelby
Beginning Member

China
88 Posts |
|
|
StephenSelby
Beginning Member

China
88 Posts |
|
|
SteveH
Forum Newbie
7 Posts |
Posted - 03/12/2010 : 06:25:35
|
Stephen - is the book you mention the Doug Cox "Backup Dobro" book?
If it is, I had a similar opinion regarding the arepeggios and such. In regards to all of these different types of chords, it would seem they apply more to solo compositions than anything else. To me, it's definitely "the dobro trying to sound like a guitar" in the sense of filling up all the space in a solo piece. In a jam or band context, I'm not so sure about their relevance. |
 |
|
|
Topic |
|