DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online resonator guitar teacher.
Monthly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, resonator guitar news and more.
|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.resohangout.com/archive/51162
macmanmatty - Posted - 05/19/2019: 08:48:20
I have a deneve square neck resonator made in the mid 90's. I may be looking to sell it to fund other gear purchases. It has a maple top walnut back and sides quarterman cone barcus-berry pick-up and one different tuning peg installed at an angle to get the screw hole to match up. How much would this guitar be worth as is and how much would it be worth if I changed the tuners to all matching ones. ? It would come with a Musicians Friend hardshell resonator guitar case, two slides, and a capo
more pics are here imgur.com/gallery/Np6JIbW
Edited by - macmanmatty on 05/19/2019 08:50:42
DBChimer - Posted - 05/19/2019: 10:38:48
I don't mean to rain on your parade, but judging by the reaction I got in my recent attempt to create buyer's interest for my immaculate Beard Mahogany R Model on this forum, be prepared for disappointment.
Disappointment in the form of price offers being made for half of what you originally paid for your instrument or even less.
The used reso market sucks right now, its just a fact of the times And the crappy part of the current sales climate, there's little chance the used reso market will improve any time in the foreseeable future.
That by no means suggests you shouldn't test the market with your instrument. Who knows you might have better luck than I had.
Wish you the best.
macmanmatty - Posted - 05/20/2019: 08:25:34
any idea of a ball park estimate value on this? Would adding better / matching tuning machines add to the value? Does the nice pick up add to the value? I'd like to get somewhere between the minimum I'd take and as much I can get. But, If as. much as I can get is less than the minimum I'd take I won't sell.
otdobro - Posted - 05/20/2019: 08:57:39
DeNeve's are a very well made instrument. In the late 1990's he started farming out the finishing work, and they were much nicer looking. The newer ones sold for about $1400 brand new, which was a real bargain. I believe he no longer makes instruments.
macmanmatty - Posted - 05/20/2019: 09:09:05
Devene still makes instruments and they are around 1500 like you stated. He had about 5 for sale last Christmas. Due regulations he no longer sells to anyone in his home state of NY I believe. I bought mine used. I was mainly wondering one how much value the pick up adds and two if that funky different offset tuner detracts from the value in any way. It has zero effect on tuning stability or playability.
Edited by - macmanmatty on 05/20/2019 09:09:42
hlpdobro - Posted - 05/20/2019: 10:59:18
Adding the correct tuner doesn't make the guitar more valuable. You should replace it anyways to make the guitar more salable.
It's a perception thing.
h
MarkinSonoma - Posted - 05/20/2019: 11:42:00
As I recall it's been many years since the Barcus-Berry surface mounted dobro pickup has been in production.
IMO it adds nothing to the value of the guitar and might even slightly detract from it. I've heard these on a couple different guitars in the past and I think they make a dobro sound more like a lap steel. So it wouldn't add any value unless when plugging in one is going for more of a lap steel sound.
As far as the overall worth of a DeNeve, you of course have to start with the price when new. $1500 or so new these days means a pretty steep drop off on the used market. Probably somewhere in the $900 range.
Edited by - MarkinSonoma on 05/20/2019 11:42:38
docslyd - Posted - 05/20/2019: 12:51:43
...I’m not sure that I believe in the resonator guitar “market”. People buy “used” or vintage guitars that are appealing, not readily available new, at an attractive price and most of all....what they want. They are too much of a niche instrument to be considered commodities.
MarkinSonoma - Posted - 05/21/2019: 10:58:40
I get what you're saying Eric. I can recall posting a similar comment from a member regarding "the market" several years ago in a thread on Reso-Nation. I was in a discussion involving the price of used Scheerhorn guitars. My logic was that if at the time Tim had built ballpark 700 instruments in his career, and there were seven for sale around the country - that's only one percent of his output as a luthier.
That is hardly what one could refer to as a "market."
In the guitar world, one could legitimately use the term "market" in reference to used Martin D-28s or Fender Telecasters. There have been many thousands of those produced over the decades.
My use above is sort of a catchall term for the idea of used lap style resonator guitars in general, and where they are priced.
In the modern era, with the exception of Tim-built Scheerhorns, they have all pretty much dropped off from their price as new. There might be the occasional guitar that pops up from a boutique builder that has been a "case queen" and in pristine condition that garners a used price close to when new, but this is pretty rare.
I wish there were an easy way to figure out how many new players have come onboard since the year 2000 and how many other players we have lost in that time to all the reasons for loss: failing health due to age, death, or loss of interest.
In the early 2000s the instrument was a on a roll attracting new players. This can be attributed to Jerry Douglas more than anyone else. Give his bandleader Alison Krauss some credit for popularizing the dobro as well when she invited him to join the band as member in 1998. Several of the AKUS albums have been certified Gold Records (sales of 500,000 or more) and the AKUS Live album from 2002 has gone Double Platinum with over two million units sold.
The first time I saw AKUS was in the '90s when Adam Steffey was in the band prior to Jerry. That was in a San Francisco venue which holds a little less than 500 people. In around the dozen times I've seen the group live, the largest venue was close to 10,000 capacity. As Alison's star became brighter, that exposed a lot of people to the playing of Jerry Douglas.
Then there was the "Oh Brother effect" after that movie became so popular and spawned two Down From the Mountain tours where the concerts filled large arenas.
There were some times in dobro history that inspired folks to take up the instrument: Josh Graves in his years with Flatt & Scruggs and Mike Auldridge with The Seldom Scene and his early solo albums (that's when I was hooked). But the exposure was considerably smaller than what AKUS has received going back to around 2000.
I think Jerry with AKUS, the "Oh Brother effect," etc. of the early 2000s was the closest thing to a "big bang" in the instrument's history. There hasn't been anything like that over the past 10 years or so.
My conclusion is that there seems to be a lot of used squareneck resonators guitar out there for sale in a variety of price categories, and maybe not enough players to absorb all these instruments and keep the prices up at a higher level.
No doubt there are a fair number transactions for used instruments that are never seen on the internet, but for the ones we do see - they aren't exactly "flying out the door."
docslyd - Posted - 05/21/2019: 11:29:31
If the number of manufacturers/builders in the last few years who have determined that there is a demand for a resonator guitar, is any indication of the number of new players "picking" it up for the first time...things should look pretty promising. Gretsch & Guild (!?) for example...not to mention the ones that have been around (Fender, National, Beard) or all of the "boutique" and smaller manufacturers who make resos as a sideline. Never have there been so many choices. I would think most of those named have determined that there is a market. (Using the term "market" in a different context here, than above.)
Edited by - docslyd on 05/21/2019 11:31:10
DBChimer - Posted - 05/21/2019: 11:47:16
Doc, I admire your theory on the appeal and emotion part of buying a used reso in today's deflated seller's market.
Unfortunately as I sadly found out, buying on appeal and emotion was completely absent in my case.
Even lowering the instrument to a fire-sale price didn't attract any attention. Nada on an offered added-value package as well.
Maybe the Beard nameplate on a reso isn't as attractive as I thought.
docslyd - Posted - 05/21/2019: 12:50:39
Consider the ready availability, although, I would think that a fair price would attract a buyer who was looking for one. Go figure. Some people would rather buy a car that's never been driven, even though they would have to pay 30% more than one that's one or two years older.
DBChimer - Posted - 05/21/2019: 14:48:37
Doc, I think you've just pressed the one hot button that is famous for its ambiguity in today's used reso market.. namely, "fair price".
What a fair price means to a seller is not necessarily what a fair price means to a buyer. The distance
between the two is often times too difficult to resolve. In many cases we're talking avocados and bananas here and the twain can't be met.
That is and will sadly remain the bone of contention between seller and buyer INMO, for as long as the current depressed market remains in effect.
So cinch up your belt if you have a reso already listed for sale or planning to do so, What you're about to experience is enough to make a grown man cry.
Edited by - DBChimer on 05/21/2019 14:53:15
resoranger - Posted - 05/25/2019: 09:44:01
I think Mark is on the money when he says the guitar is worth around 60 % of new selling price. I have always felt that most average condition used reso guitars are priced on the high side realizing there are exceptions to this rule like guitars that are just like brand new or rare. I am curious what others think is a fair price on an average condition used guitar compared to its new selling price. What is a fair percent off on a like new guitar for sale?
Edited by - resoranger on 05/25/2019 09:54:01
DBChimer - Posted - 05/25/2019: 12:16:16
Speaking from recent experience trying to sell a mint condition Beard Mahogany R Body, I think the sell price would be closer to 50% of new, if not slightly less.
Three major reasons for this IMO: reduced interest in resonator guitars in general, money is a lot tighter than previously imagined, a gluttony of low priced fairly decent new and used entry level guitars are currently on the market.
The premier nameplate dobro market is dead. The used and low-price dobro is barely able to fog a mirror.
macmanmatty - Posted - 07/23/2019: 13:09:52
now for sale 1200 or OBO will have correct tuning machine installed and new strings. Comes with a slide, resonator capo and a set of finger picks as well as a new musicians friend hard shell square-neck resonator case.
Edited by - macmanmatty on 07/23/2019 13:13:38
macmanmatty - Posted - 07/27/2019: 11:22:36
Since it was mentioned earlier that the Barcus Berry Hi Tek Pickup would not add much if anything to the value or possibly even detract from it and I see them selling on ebay for around 200 would it be worth while to take the pick up out and sell it separately?
DBChimer - Posted - 07/27/2019: 12:05:47
I'd say a definite yes! If by removing the pickup you're not leaving ugly, gaping holes anywhere...go for it.
macmanmatty - Posted - 07/27/2019: 13:13:21
would a 3/8' hole in the lower bout side for the 1/4" output jack qualify as ugly and gaping?
DBChimer - Posted - 07/27/2019: 14:57:16
Pretty close. Then again, without being able to see it in person, hard to tell just how much.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Reso Hangout. All Rights Reserved.