Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Regal RD-56 (blacklighing RN) vs Recording king professional RN

Sep 22, 2026 - 6:24:23 AM
likes this

mik666

USA

16 posts since 5/10/2024

Hey all - i'm thinking about get a decent asian reso for camping/banging around as my other spider guitars are 30's prewars and i don't want to subject them too potential adverse ending conditions - i want a dobro with sound ring as don't really like the soundwell less sound and a 1 3/4 at the nut size. i see the Regal rd-56 is the newish blacklighting round neck (about $700) and the recording king professional (a bit over 800) - i have an extra #14 spider and Quarterman cone for upgrading from left over experimentations - any opinions? i imagine they are probably made in the same factory and look pretty similar has anyone compared them head to head - orhave any thought on either?
thx
Mike

Sep 22, 2026 - 6:56:54 AM

skydog

USA

204 posts since 10/28/2008

I have a RC-55 that’s fun to play. I keep it in DADF#AD usually. I’m not sure how close in specs it is to the 56. It’s a biscuit bridge. I replaced the cone with a Beard Legend that helped it a lot. resohangout.com/forum/attachme...eID=42555


 

Sep 22, 2026 - 11:40:18 AM
likes this

tomkatb

USA

463 posts since 1/31/2015

I asked the late Frank Harlow the same sort of question.

At the time, several years ago he recommended the black lightning.

I paid a jerk $400 for it. He dropped it and broke the neck loose so it was basically worthless. Rather than Fight I gave it to Frank. My friend. He said I will take are of it.

He installed the #14 spider and Quarterman cone. And reset the neck.

We often travel to San Francisco and that guitar goes with me. But, not until next year.

The other one could be better. I do not know.

It is my practice and travel guitar. At bluegrass jams they prefer I bring one of the Harlows. i kind of prefer old country music playing which the lightning does better.

Mine is not for sale.

Sep 23, 2026 - 3:31:55 PM
likes this

5238 posts since 7/27/2008

I can't speak to the roundneck part - I'm a lap style player who has occasionally dabbled in roundneck bottleneck slide reso.

But I have played a number of both guitars over the years in the squareneck versions, and I preferred the Recording King. 

"Hot rodding" a resonator after buying the stock version is one thing - but I'm basing my opinion on having played them as stock in guitar stores. Even though the Black Lightning used to come with the no longer available Quarterman cone, they would always sound somewhat "muffled" to me. Hard to describe. One thing for sure I didn't like and maybe it's better now - the spider bridge that came with the guitar was horrible. If I had one, along with a good cone I would probably order a #14 spider from Beard. But now it's starting to get expernsive...

Sep 23, 2026 - 7:38:27 PM
likes this

447 posts since 9/24/2014

I had a Black Lightning, I got it used so I can't say if it was modded but I really don't think so, it was a real nice Dobro, I'd compare it favorably to the OMI's I started out on. My friend has it now and loves it, I play a couple 30s Regals now.

Sep 24, 2026 - 5:59:04 AM

mik666

USA

16 posts since 5/10/2024

thx Guys - it looks like the recording kings are a 25.5 scale and the Regal is 25 scale - so that may play into since all my 30s dobros are a 25 scale. Like i mentioned i have an extra #14 beard spider and quaterman cone so it sounds like i should just keep an eye out for a used regal or recording king and if the price is right go for it since if i'm planning on replacing the cone/spider paying for a new instrument is a bit of an overpriced venture

Sep 24, 2026 - 6:03:39 AM
likes this

skydog

USA

204 posts since 10/28/2008

Down Home Guitars had a couple of nice Regals earlier this year. They weren’t listed on the website you’ll have to ask.

Sep 27, 2026 - 5:09:26 AM

mik666

USA

16 posts since 5/10/2024

thx All - i found a Gretsch "boxcar" with the fishman PU for under $400 - wasn't on my radar but for the cost i figure can't go wrong as i can resell pretty easily if not happy with it -it will be interesting to see how it is stock and how my extra upgrade parts with benefit it 
best mike

Edited by - mik666 on 09/27/2026 05:10:32

Sep 27, 2026 - 8:55:38 AM
likes this

916 posts since 1/18/2012

that’s a good deal. The Fishman nashville PU with spider sells for $330 all by itself.

Edited by - Lounge Primate on 09/27/2026 08:56:01

Sep 27, 2026 - 11:10:37 AM
likes this

skydog

USA

204 posts since 10/28/2008

When I was looking for a used Goldtone PBS there was nothing available. Almost as soon as I bought a new one, several great buys showed up on used ones!

Sep 28, 2026 - 4:23:54 AM
likes this

mik666

USA

16 posts since 5/10/2024

its like when you buy "that special" car - once you have it you notice everyone has one - l o l

Sep 28, 2026 - 4:32:01 AM
likes this

skydog

USA

204 posts since 10/28/2008

quote:
Originally posted by mik666

its like when you buy "that special" car - once you have it you notice everyone has one - l o l


I wouldn't have called it "special", but I bought a 2002 Ford Escape which was their second year of production. Shortly after I started seeing them more and more. Now, they're everywhere.

Oct 4, 2026 - 6:32:33 AM

mik666

USA

16 posts since 5/10/2024

So i got the Gretsch - impression of it with new strings and thats it - mehh - kind of muffled sound, bass strings lack any kinda of definition - but playability was decent -and its got a small body which was nice for us lovers of smaller resobodies, -similair to 30's dobro size, neck was a V shape which i liked a lot. Opening it up has sound well with trapazoid holes very similiar to 30's California dobro's. the spider was a smooth AL looking thing that was almost flat - and while it didn't weigh a lot (128 grams or so) defiantly had less of a "ping" when suspended and tapped with a screwdriver compared to #14- same could be said of the cone compared to a Quaterman and a sherrhorn (?) spares i had. tried both cones with the #14 spider - both sounded way better than the stock setup (didn't try the stock spider) with both cones - ended going with the sheerhorn and with the stock fishman pickup inserted in the bridge sounded really good ran through the aura pedal - bass much better - great blues tone. still need minor adjustment as height a bit high at 12 fret (close to 3.00mm)
Conclusion -f i had paid for a new one - i would of been disappointed for sure - but for $400 with the fishman pickup installed and having the spare parts gathering dust (so saying no $) its great deal - especially as a travel / camping guitar and a open mic guitar for bars that may be a bit on the shady side

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Reso Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.2148438